The Hero Who Got Promoted Has to Learn to Build Heroes

One of the biggest challenges a leader faces in becoming strategic is shifting from being the hero to being the leader who builds heroes on the team. It’s a silent obstacle that can go unaddressed until you realize your star performer isn’t stepping up to the senior leader role the way you thought they would.

This is one of the hardest shifts I see in my Get Strategic 30 clients. It’s not just a skills gap. It’s also an identity gap, and it doesn’t resolve itself with time and experience. You have to work on it intentionally.

Why does the hero get promoted?

Part of the problem is the reward system in most organizations. The high performer gets the promotion because of their record, the visibility of their achievements, and the results they’ve delivered. It’s very much an individual endeavor.

And ironically, firefighting often gets the most attention because it’s the most visible and dramatic. The heroic firefighter gets noticed by executive leadership, while the team member who builds systems and runs things so there aren’t fires gets less recognition.

As I wrote in my last blog post, The Work That Always Waits Until Next Week, solving a problem in the moment is a dopamine rush. Everyone can see the save. But firefighting is not a way to run a business. When you’re always reacting, you aren’t the one defining your destiny.

People notice what gets rewarded in an organization, and that becomes their definition of success and high performance. People learn that the person who makes the basket gets the promotion, not the one who made the assist.

But the leader’s job is much bigger and more strategic. It’s about finding the root causes of the fires, figuring out why there are so many, and preventing them. It’s about building a team that can deliver without needing a hero.

Two gaps stand in the way of making a strategic leadership transition: one is an identity gap and the other is a capability gap.

What does the identity gap look like?

A leader I work with, newly promoted to a senior role, recently championed an idea from someone on his team. He elevated it to his executive team, made the case, and got it moving. Then he waved off any credit. “It wasn’t my idea,” he said. “I can’t take credit.”

He didn’t see the win in that. But championing someone else’s idea forward is the strategic leader’s work. That was the job, and he did it well.

That’s the identity gap. For years you’ve been the person who makes the basket, not the assist. Your wins were your wins, and everyone could see that. Now the wins are the team’s, and if you only count the ones you personally made, you’ll miss the vast majority of the good work you’re actually doing.

Your motivation has to be different, and the way you define wins has to be different. The wins are far less dramatic. A strategic leader doing the job well looks like steady state, really. Things are running well, there are far fewer fires, and the team can handle more without you. It’s very hard to feel good about that if you’re used to the excitement of the save.

What does the capability gap look like?

The capability side is knowing how to do the assist.

Here’s what it might look like. You’re in a meeting, and you raise a question you know the answer to because you know it will give someone on your team the opportunity to think about it, answer it, and develop as a result. That’s the assist. Do that consistently and you’re creating the opportunities for your team to step up. Your confidence comes from the questions you ask and not the answers you have.

You rarely get training on these softer capabilities. You know how to motivate yourself and prioritize yourself. Now you have to do it at a higher level, for a whole group, and that is very, very different. It takes a whole skill set: getting strategic, knowing where to focus for the highest impact, and helping a team prioritize a broader set of goals.

The biggest pushback I get is “I can’t hand this off. My people aren’t ready.” If that’s where you are, then your number one job as a leader is to develop them. Until you do, you’ll keep being the hero, and you’ll never become the kind of leader who can, in fact, enable everyone else.

What’s in it for your organization?

As a strategic leader, your aim is to be a force multiplier. The value you bring to the business by being a brilliant individual performer is dwarfed by the value you create by having seven absolutely brilliant performers on your team.

The organization also becomes less reliant on the heroic efforts of one individual. It’s more stable in that the talent is distributed across the team.

What if you’d rather be the star player?

Admittedly, some people may not want to give up the spotlight. Some prefer being star players to coaching a championship team, and that’s okay. Not everyone is the right fit for a senior leadership role, and it’s better to be honest about that early.

Where do you start?

Start by being absolutely honest about how you defined success before your promotion. What genuinely motivated you in that role?

Then look at the role you’re in now. What does it look like when you and your team are delivering at the highest level? Get a very clear picture of how the two might be different.

Then ask yourself: Do I have the capabilities to build the heroes on my team? Is it something I’ve done before? And if not, what do I need to do to close those gaps? You might need training, professional development, or support from someone who’s helped other leaders through it.

This is the work I do with leaders in the Get Strategic 30 program, because leaders who work on both identity and capability are the ones who make the shift from executor to strategic leader.

Idea to Action

This week, set aside 30 minutes and write down your answers to three questions:

  1. What is success for me individually?
  2. What does success look like for my team?
  3. What is success for the organization?

Then read them side by side and check whether they line up. If your answer to the first question is still about the baskets you make yourself, you’ve found where to start.

Work well,

Adriana

Ready to make the shift from executor to strategic leader?

Get Strategic 30 is my 30-week program for leaders who want to become strategic by design, building the habit and the systems that protect strategic work for good, in months instead of years.

Book a Get Strategic Exploratory Call
Learn about Get Strategic 30

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do star performers struggle after a promotion to senior leadership?

Because the senior role asks for something different from what got them promoted. Most organizations promote the high performer for their individual record and visible results, and firefighting gets the most attention. The senior leader’s job is to find the root causes of the fires, prevent them, and build a team that can deliver without needing a hero. Two gaps stand in the way: an identity gap and a capability gap.

What is the identity gap in leadership?

The identity gap is the shift in how a leader defines a win. For years their wins were their own, and everyone could see them. In a senior role the wins belong to the team, and a leader who only counts the ones they made personally will miss most of the good work they’re doing. A strategic leader doing the job well looks like steady state: things running well, far fewer fires, and a team that can handle more without them.

What does it mean for a leader to make the assist?

Making the assist means creating the opportunity for someone on your team to step up. For example, in a meeting you raise a question you already know the answer to, so someone on your team can think it through, answer it, and develop as a result. Done consistently, the leader’s confidence comes from the questions they ask and not the answers they have.

What if my people aren’t ready for me to hand work off?

Then your number one job as a leader is to develop them. Until you do, you’ll keep being the hero, and you’ll never become the kind of leader who can enable everyone else.

Adriana McLane

Adriana McLane

I help privately held distributors build strategy that holds up through growth, leadership transition, and what comes next. Fifteen years running Fulfilling Strategy, the last six spent deep inside distribution, working alongside the leadership of privately held distribution companies to build strategy that holds when a competitor moves in on your territory, when a President steps back, and when the next generation takes the lead. More about Adriana →